artifactStrategy & discovery

Business Case

An evidence-based justification for an investment that compares options, expected benefits, costs, risks, affordability, and delivery conditions.

Download Markdown (.md)

01What it means

A business case is a decision artifact that explains why an investment should proceed, which options were considered, and why a preferred option is justified. It brings together strategic fit, expected value, costs, risks, commercial and financial considerations, and delivery arrangements; it is broader than a revenue forecast or feature pitch.[1][2]

One investment decision viewed through connected evidence Compare the preferred option with credible alternatives and doing nothing
Problem + outcomes
Why change and what success would mean
Strategic fit
How the investment advances direction
Options
Do nothing, alternatives, and preferred approach
Benefits
Expected value, timing, owners, and evidence
Costs + affordability
Lifecycle resources and funding constraints
Risks + dependencies
Uncertainty, obligations, and external conditions
Delivery conditions
Capability, governance, and review points
Recommendation
Choice, assumptions, and decision thresholds

A business case cannot remove uncertainty; its assumptions, benefits, costs, and continued justification must remain reviewable after approval.

02Why it matters

Product investments compete for scarce money and capacity. A proportionate business case makes assumptions and alternatives inspectable, supports go or no-go decisions, and creates a basis for revisiting whether continued investment remains worthwhile.

03When to use it

Use it for material, costly, regulated, cross-organizational, or hard-to-reverse investments. Scale its depth to uncertainty and consequence; a small reversible experiment usually needs a lightweight rationale rather than a long approval document.

04How it works

  1. Describe the problem, strategic context, desired outcomes, and do-nothing baseline.
  2. Develop credible options rather than defending only a preferred solution.
  3. Estimate benefits, costs, risks, dependencies, affordability, and delivery feasibility.
  4. Compare options transparently and recommend one with explicit assumptions.
  5. Agree ownership, success measures, review points, and decision thresholds.
  6. Update or withdraw the case when evidence changes its justification.

05A practical example

Example

A retailer considers replacing its returns platform. The business case compares improving the current system, buying a service, and building a new platform against doing nothing, including customer impact, fraud risk, migration cost, operating cost, and delivery capability. Leaders fund a staged replacement with review gates.

06Where it breaks

Forecasts can create false precision and are vulnerable to optimism, sunk-cost defense, and strategic exaggeration. A business case cannot remove uncertainty, and approval can become theater if assumptions and benefits are never reviewed after funding.

Common mistakes

  • Writing the case after a solution has already been selected.
  • Omitting the do-nothing option and meaningful alternatives.
  • Counting benefits without costs, risks, timing, or ownership.
  • Treating approval as permanent justification for continued investment.

07Sources

  1. What Is a Business Case?Association for Project Management · Professional body guidanceWhat Is a Business Case?
  2. Guidance on Developing Business CasesHM Treasury · Government guidanceGuidance on Developing Business Cases
View saved topics

Start typing to search titles, definitions, categories, and frameworks.