Business Case
An evidence-based justification for an investment that compares options, expected benefits, costs, risks, affordability, and delivery conditions.
Download Markdown (.md)Soroush’s Product Wiki · https://wiki.soroush.uk/topic/business-case/
01What it means
A business case is a decision artifact that explains why an investment should proceed, which options were considered, and why a preferred option is justified. It brings together strategic fit, expected value, costs, risks, commercial and financial considerations, and delivery arrangements; it is broader than a revenue forecast or feature pitch.[1][2]
- Problem + outcomes
- Why change and what success would mean
- Strategic fit
- How the investment advances direction
- Options
- Do nothing, alternatives, and preferred approach
- Benefits
- Expected value, timing, owners, and evidence
- Costs + affordability
- Lifecycle resources and funding constraints
- Risks + dependencies
- Uncertainty, obligations, and external conditions
- Delivery conditions
- Capability, governance, and review points
- Recommendation
- Choice, assumptions, and decision thresholds
A business case cannot remove uncertainty; its assumptions, benefits, costs, and continued justification must remain reviewable after approval.
02Why it matters
Product investments compete for scarce money and capacity. A proportionate business case makes assumptions and alternatives inspectable, supports go or no-go decisions, and creates a basis for revisiting whether continued investment remains worthwhile.
03When to use it
Use it for material, costly, regulated, cross-organizational, or hard-to-reverse investments. Scale its depth to uncertainty and consequence; a small reversible experiment usually needs a lightweight rationale rather than a long approval document.
04How it works
- Describe the problem, strategic context, desired outcomes, and do-nothing baseline.
- Develop credible options rather than defending only a preferred solution.
- Estimate benefits, costs, risks, dependencies, affordability, and delivery feasibility.
- Compare options transparently and recommend one with explicit assumptions.
- Agree ownership, success measures, review points, and decision thresholds.
- Update or withdraw the case when evidence changes its justification.
05A practical example
A retailer considers replacing its returns platform. The business case compares improving the current system, buying a service, and building a new platform against doing nothing, including customer impact, fraud risk, migration cost, operating cost, and delivery capability. Leaders fund a staged replacement with review gates.
06Where it breaks
Forecasts can create false precision and are vulnerable to optimism, sunk-cost defense, and strategic exaggeration. A business case cannot remove uncertainty, and approval can become theater if assumptions and benefits are never reviewed after funding.
Common mistakes
- Writing the case after a solution has already been selected.
- Omitting the do-nothing option and meaningful alternatives.
- Counting benefits without costs, risks, timing, or ownership.
- Treating approval as permanent justification for continued investment.
07Sources
- What Is a Business Case?Association for Project Management · Professional body guidanceWhat Is a Business Case?
- Guidance on Developing Business CasesHM Treasury · Government guidanceGuidance on Developing Business Cases