Discussion Guide
A flexible session script that translates research questions into a consistent flow of neutral topics, prompts, activities, and follow-ups.
Download Markdown (.md)Soroush’s Product Wiki · https://wiki.soroush.uk/topic/discussion-guide/
01What it means
A discussion guide is a structured but adaptable aid for moderated interviews, focus groups, and related studies. It includes the introduction and consent reminders, topic sequence, open prompts, possible probes, activities, and closing, while leaving room to follow relevant participant experiences.[1][2]
- 01Welcome + consentPurpose, recording, rights, rapport, and expectations
- 02ContextRecent experience, environment, goals, and current alternatives
- 03Core topicsNeutral prompts tied to the research questions
- 04Activities + probesTasks, artifacts, examples, and specific follow-up
- 05Wrap-upMissing context, participant questions, next steps, and withdrawal route
A guide supports consistency without becoming a script that suppresses follow-up; neutral wording and realistic activities matter more than asking every question.
02Why it matters
A guide keeps sessions aligned with research objectives and makes coverage more consistent across facilitators and participants. Piloting it reveals leading wording, unrealistic timing, and missing transitions before they damage a full round.
03When to use it
Use a guide for moderated qualitative sessions or any study where several facilitators need comparable coverage. A rigid script is inappropriate when following an unfolding observation matters more than asking every planned question.
04How it works
- Turn each prioritized research question into topics rather than asking it directly.
- Arrange an introduction, easy context questions, core topics or tasks, sensitive material, and a close.
- Write open neutral prompts and optional probes for concrete examples, actions, and consequences.
- Include consent, recording, accessibility, timing, stimuli, and facilitator notes.
- Pilot the guide, remove leading or redundant prompts, and adapt it transparently during the round.
05A practical example
A team exploring subscription cancellation begins with recent account-management experiences, asks for the last concrete cancellation, then probes decisions and consequences before showing any proposed flow, preventing the concept from shaping problem evidence.
06Where it breaks
Consistent wording cannot remove moderator effects or recall bias. An overfilled guide leads to shallow answers, while strict adherence can suppress unexpected but decision-relevant evidence.
Common mistakes
- Copying research questions directly into jargon-heavy participant prompts.
- Asking leading, compound, or hypothetical questions instead of eliciting concrete experiences.
- Treating the guide as a questionnaire that must be followed word for word.
07Sources
- Using in-depth interviewsGOV.UK Service Manual · Government service guidanceUsing in-depth interviews
- Plan a round of user researchGOV.UK Service Manual · Government service guidancePlan a round of user research