Problem Framing
The practice of defining which problem a team will address, for whom, in what context, and with what outcome and constraints.
Download Markdown (.md)Soroush’s Product Wiki · https://wiki.soroush.uk/topic/problem-framing/
01What it means
Problem framing turns a broad situation, symptom, or request into a useful design challenge. A strong frame identifies affected people, relevant context, evidence, desired change, boundaries, and open questions without quietly prescribing a single solution.[1][2]
- People affected
- Whose experience, rights, and outcomes matter
- Context
- Situation, triggers, environment, and current alternatives
- Observed problem
- Evidence of unmet need, harm, or opportunity
- Desired outcome
- Meaningful change without prescribing a feature
- System boundary
- What is inside, outside, and connected
- Constraints
- Policy, technology, ethics, time, and capability
- Assumptions
- Unverified beliefs the frame depends on
- Success evidence
- Signals that would support or challenge the frame
A frame is provisional and value-laden; involve affected people and revisit it when evidence shows the wrong problem, boundary, or outcome.
02Why it matters
The frame controls where a team looks and what it considers possible. A narrow or solution-shaped frame can waste excellent execution, while a frame that is too broad produces generic ideas. Making the frame explicit allows assumptions and stakeholder differences to be examined early.
03When to use it
Use it at the start of discovery, when a roadmap item arrives as a feature request, when research contradicts the original brief, or when stakeholders propose incompatible solutions. Revisit it whenever new evidence changes the perceived problem.
04How it works
- Separate observed evidence from interpretations, requests, and preferred solutions.
- Identify the people, situations, behaviors, and outcomes that matter.
- Map system constraints, incentives, stakeholders, and potential harms.
- Write several candidate frames at different levels of scope.
- Choose a frame that is actionable yet leaves room for multiple responses.
- State assumptions and questions that discovery must resolve.
05A practical example
A marketplace request to “add seller ratings” is reframed after research. Buyers actually struggle to judge whether a seller will dispatch on time. The team frames the challenge as helping buyers assess fulfillment reliability before purchase, opening options beyond a single reputation score.
06Where it breaks
Every frame includes some perspectives and excludes others; it is never neutral. Teams can endlessly reframe to avoid commitment, or wordsmith a statement without gathering evidence. Complex structural problems may not be responsibly reduced to one user-centered challenge.
Common mistakes
- Writing the proposed feature into the problem statement.
- Framing around an internal metric without describing customer context.
- Treating the first frame as fixed after new evidence appears.
07Sources
- Design Project Scoping GuideStanford d.school · Institutional method guideDesign Project Scoping Guide
- How Might We QuestionsStanford d.school · Institutional method guideHow Might We Questions